by Ganesh Sahathevan
Mark Speakman AG is considered
a replacement for Gladys Berejiklian
With regards the cover-up:
And now, read on:
Saturday, December 21, 2019
Zhu Minshen's law school approvals involved the highest levels of the NSW Supreme Court administration: Chief Justice Bathurst and AG Speakman ultimately responsible for approvals & renewals which were granted despite Dastiyari scandal, Zhu's defiance of AFP directives
by Ganesh Sahathevan
NSW LPAB Chairman Bathurst who granted Top Group its history making right to issue LLB degrees will stay in job till 2023: Bathurst CJ will be around to swear in Top Group law grads as officers of His Honour's Court.
The New South Wales Legal Profession Admission Board, which provided Zhu Minshen's HK listed Top Education Group Ltd its approval and later renewal of its license to issue law degrees in Australia seems to have had an interesting year.
In less than a year after it appointed an outsider as Executive Officer, it advertised the position as if vacant, apparently seeking a replacement.It is unclear if Ms Tan Siew Ting Mckeogh was being replaced, or whether the advertisement was simply the usual NSW Public Service method of re-advertising a position that has already been filled.
Ms Tan McKeogh signed-off the LPAB's 2018-2019 Annual Report as Acting Executive Officer.
Confirmation is not possible given the LPAB's refusal to answer any questions about its work; it has been evasive on a number of matters, including its failure to report complaints against it and the College Of Law Sydney, which it regulates, in the relevant 2017-2018 Annual Report. This evasiveness has extended to the practise of issuing letters unsigned, and simply marking them "on behalf of the Board" if at all.
Nevertheless, the advertisement has provided some insight into the Executive Officer's functions and powers.It is clear from the position description that the Executive Officer could not but have had a significant part to play in the approval and later review and renewal of Zhu Minshen and Top Group's license to issue LLBs.
The advertisement also provides insight into who the Executive Officer's superiors are. While the Executive Officer wields considerable power within the LPAB, the LPAB itself is chaired by the Chief Justice Of NSW, Thomas Bathurst.
In addition the advertisement states that the Executive Officer also reports to the Executive Director, Superior Courts.Chris D'Aeth. D'Aeth has been Executive Director and Principal Registrar of the Supreme Court NSW since 2015.He would therefore have overseen Top Group's initial application, and more recent review which "went smoothly" despite the issues surrounding the matter(see story below). As reported, this included an account from Professor Clive Hamilton of how Zhu organised student demonstrationsin Canberra in defiance of AFP directives.
The Chief Justice and the minister in charge, the Attorney General NSW Mark Speakman have continued to remain silent on all of the above despite extensive reporting on Top Group and Zhu Minshe's dealings (see also New Matilda story below).
END
Labor Senator Sam Dastyari.
Former Prime Minister Tony Abbott, pictured with Minshen Zhu.
NSW LPAB Chairman Bathurst who granted Top Group its history making right to issue LLB degrees will stay in job till 2023: Bathurst CJ will be around to swear in Top Group law grads as officers of His Honour's Court.
The New South Wales Legal Profession Admission Board, which provided Zhu Minshen's HK listed Top Education Group Ltd its approval and later renewal of its license to issue law degrees in Australia seems to have had an interesting year.
In less than a year after it appointed an outsider as Executive Officer, it advertised the position as if vacant, apparently seeking a replacement.It is unclear if Ms Tan Siew Ting Mckeogh was being replaced, or whether the advertisement was simply the usual NSW Public Service method of re-advertising a position that has already been filled.
Ms Tan McKeogh signed-off the LPAB's 2018-2019 Annual Report as Acting Executive Officer.
Confirmation is not possible given the LPAB's refusal to answer any questions about its work; it has been evasive on a number of matters, including its failure to report complaints against it and the College Of Law Sydney, which it regulates, in the relevant 2017-2018 Annual Report. This evasiveness has extended to the practise of issuing letters unsigned, and simply marking them "on behalf of the Board" if at all.
Nevertheless, the advertisement has provided some insight into the Executive Officer's functions and powers.It is clear from the position description that the Executive Officer could not but have had a significant part to play in the approval and later review and renewal of Zhu Minshen and Top Group's license to issue LLBs.
The advertisement also provides insight into who the Executive Officer's superiors are. While the Executive Officer wields considerable power within the LPAB, the LPAB itself is chaired by the Chief Justice Of NSW, Thomas Bathurst.
In addition the advertisement states that the Executive Officer also reports to the Executive Director, Superior Courts.Chris D'Aeth. D'Aeth has been Executive Director and Principal Registrar of the Supreme Court NSW since 2015.He would therefore have overseen Top Group's initial application, and more recent review which "went smoothly" despite the issues surrounding the matter(see story below). As reported, this included an account from Professor Clive Hamilton of how Zhu organised student demonstrationsin Canberra in defiance of AFP directives.
The Chief Justice and the minister in charge, the Attorney General NSW Mark Speakman have continued to remain silent on all of the above despite extensive reporting on Top Group and Zhu Minshe's dealings (see also New Matilda story below).
END
Friday, September 27, 2019
Zhu Minshen announces that NSW LPAB review "went smoothly": AG NSW Mark Speakman and officers unconcerned by Clive Hamilton's disclosures of threats, intimidation and defiance of AFP directives ,share price collapse
by Ganesh Sahathevan
The LPAB''s tick of approval does not seem to have reversed the downward trend in share price.Indeed it does look as if the LPAB has ignored all together the fact that Top's market capitalisation has collapsed since listing. Note that Top's shareprice has fallen 14.29% over the past month,compared to 1.13% for the overall market as measured by the Hang Seng Index
In the words of Zhu Minshen, chairman and CEO of his Top Education Group Ltd:
Bachelor of Law Re-accreditation
The scheduled re-accreditation process of our Bachelor of Laws (‘‘LLB’’) went smoothly. On 27 June 2019, TOP received formal notification from the Legal Profession Admission Board of New South Wales (‘‘LPAB’’) to accredit TOP’s LLB for a further five-year period commencing from the notification date.
(TOP EDUCATION GROUP LTD
ANNOUNCEMENT OF ANNUAL RESULTSFOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2019)
All this despite the revelations of open defiance of an AFP directive, threats and intimidation disclosed in Clive Hamilton's "Silent Invasion",which have been previously reported on this blog:
In his 2018 book "Silent Invasion" Professor Clive Hamilton reports that Top Education Group's Zhu Minshen organised students , including students from his Top Education Institute to protest against Tibetans at the 2008 rally , which counted towards the Top students’ assessment. Zhu’s Top Institution is “perhaps the only accredited degree program in Australia that counts agitating for a foreign power towards its qualifications.”
Hamilton provides details of Zhu's Communist Party China antecedents and his organisation of the 30,000 strong demonstration by Chinese students at the Canberra torch relay, many of them brandishing Chinese flags.
END
See Also
In the words of Zhu Minshen, chairman and CEO of his Top Education Group Ltd:
Bachelor of Law Re-accreditation
The scheduled re-accreditation process of our Bachelor of Laws (‘‘LLB’’) went smoothly. On 27 June 2019, TOP received formal notification from the Legal Profession Admission Board of New South Wales (‘‘LPAB’’) to accredit TOP’s LLB for a further five-year period commencing from the notification date.
(TOP EDUCATION GROUP LTD
ANNOUNCEMENT OF ANNUAL RESULTSFOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2019)
All this despite the revelations of open defiance of an AFP directive, threats and intimidation disclosed in Clive Hamilton's "Silent Invasion",which have been previously reported on this blog:
In his 2018 book "Silent Invasion" Professor Clive Hamilton reports that Top Education Group's Zhu Minshen organised students , including students from his Top Education Institute to protest against Tibetans at the 2008 rally , which counted towards the Top students’ assessment. Zhu’s Top Institution is “perhaps the only accredited degree program in Australia that counts agitating for a foreign power towards its qualifications.”
Hamilton provides details of Zhu's Communist Party China antecedents and his organisation of the 30,000 strong demonstration by Chinese students at the Canberra torch relay, many of them brandishing Chinese flags.
This was clearly an open challenge to the authority , and in public defiance of, the AFP's directive to Chinese government security that they were not to be involved in the torch relay. As Hamilton puts is "ASIO shat themselves".
Despite this open defiance of the law that they are meant to defend and uphold the Attorney General NSW Mark Speakman and the other senior judicial officers at the LPAB determined that an exception should be made to allow Zhu to operate the "first and only" law school in Australia that is not part of a university.
END
See Also
Law Council Australia 's exception for Zhu Minshen despite Law Council declaring China's justice system "a joke"
Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull pictured with Top Education's Minshen Zhu.
A Top Education? Dastyari’s Donations Troubles Expose The College With Impeccable Connections
A top education? Sam Dastyari’s donations trouble exposes the private college with impeccable connections.
Labor Senator Sam Dastyari has found himself under considerable scrutiny this week over a donation he received from Sydney’s Top Education Institute.
There is no doubt that Sam Dastyari is close to the Top Education Institute – otherwise he could scarcely have called on them to pay his parliamentary travel bill when he exceeded its cap. Close scrutiny has now also revealed that his disclosures on interstate travel have been sloppy, to say the least.
But Dastyari is not the only one to have links to Top Education. The private college is well-known in the corridors of power. Top Education’s director Minshen Zhu is one of the best-connected foreign donors in the country.
Labor Senator Sam Dastyari.The Top Education Institute is headquartered in the Biotechnology Building of inner Sydney’s Australian Technology Park. It was the first Australian college to be on the Chinese government’s approved list of tertiary institutions. Top Education has achieved the prestigious TEQSA certification to offer Bachelors’ degrees. It is the only non-university institute to offer Australian-accredited law degrees at undergraduate level. This course was originally only approved with conditions in 2013, but was fully accredited without conditions in 2015.
Top Education’s chairperson Minshen Zhu is reported to have close links with the Chinese government, though exactly how close is difficult to ascertain. An ANU graduate, Dr Zhu was a board member of the Confucius Institute of the University of Sydney. He has been a delegate to the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference, a consultative body that implies political influence. In 2012, former foreign minister Bob Carr also appointed him to a Chinese Ministerial Consultative Committee.
Criticism of Dastyari, particularly from Liberal Party senators such as Cory Bernardi and George Brandis, has focussed on Top Education’s links with the Chinese government. This is ironic. The public record shows that the Liberal Party also seems to enjoy close connections with Dr Zhu and the Top Education Institute.
Dr Zhu has been remarkably adept at convincing Australian politicians to help promote and market his institution. Indeed his college has received extraordinary attention from the most senior members of the LNP government.
Former Prime Minister Tony Abbott, pictured with Minshen Zhu.As prime ministers, both Malcolm Turnbull and before him Tony Abbott found time to attend Top Education functions. Fairfax yesterday reported that he also met with Attorney-General George Brandis in April this year, and with Treasurer Scott Morrison in November 2015.
The payment of Senator Dastyari’s travel bill has caused him considerable embarrassment. But Dastyari’s $1,670 travel invoice is just a small indication of Top Education’s political largesse. Top Education has donated handsomely to both major parties in recent years. While Top Education initially favoured the ALP in donations, since the Liberal Party came to power in 2013, Top Education’s donations have shifted to the federal and New South Wales branches of the Liberals.
Australian Electoral Commission registries indicate that the Australian Labor Party has received at least $186,000 from Top Education since 2010. Between 2014 and 2015, Top Education has donated $44,275 to the Liberal national and New South Wales branches. Unusually, the Top Education Institute itself did not disclose any of its donations to the ALP to the AEC. They were disclosed by the ALP.
Dr Zhu and Top Education have also built plenty of face-to-face connections with top Liberal politicians. He is well-known in the party rooms of Parliament. Simple internet searches can easily find photos of Top Education’s supremo with Malcolm Turnbull, George Brandis and Julia Gillard.
There is also video footage and Facebook photos of Alex Hawke (now the Assistant Minister for Immigration and Border Security) speaking at the Top Education Institute on July 27 2015. Hawke was there on behalf of Tony Abbott and Christopher Pyne, then the education minister. He even read out a special message from the Prime Minister. Such favours have been frugally bestowed on Australian public universities, who were at that stage engaged in fractious negotiations with Pyne over the govenrment’s policy of university fee deregulation.
Abbott and Pyne were already well-acquainted with the Top Education Institute. They met with the Institute’s senior management in September 2013, just a fortnight after the Abbott government was elected. On Top Education’s website, you can see a photo with Abbott prominently featured. He is pictured holding a brochure for the Institute’s new law school. The close relationship with the government has endured after Abbott’s demise as prime minister. On November 7 2015, Turnbull was photographed holding a course brochure at a dinner with Dr Zhu.
Yesterday, Attorney General George Brandis was keen to distinguish the payment of personal debt from political donations. “Indeed, many of us have met Mr Minshen Zhu and had dealings with the Top Education Institute but it appears only Senator Sam Dastyari has accepted money from him in settlement of a personal debt,” he told the Senate. Ordinary voters may question this distinction.
Dr Zhu’s big donations at ALP functions
The ALP has been Top Education’s most favoured donation recipient, with at least $186,000 donated to state and federal branches of the Labor Party since 2010. New Matilda attempted to contact ALP Federal Secretary George Wright about the ALP donations but ALP head office said that he was away and not available for comment. New Matilda understands that multiple donations from Top Education Institute are classified as ‘other receipts’ because they were paid at functions and events, rather than as financial gifts without any benefit in return.
The practice throws a spotlight on the increasing popularity of these ‘other receipts” as a category for donations disclosures. As Crikey’s Bernard Keane argued yesterday, “‘Other receipt’ is especially useful because any payment of any kind other than a donation — such as a tax refund, bank interest or a legitimate asset sale — gets lumped into that category, further reducing the clarity of disclosure.”
A donations spree in a time of higher education deregulation
The policy context for Top Education’s donations spree is instructive. Under a policy begun by the Gillard government and continued under the Coalition governments of Tony Abbott and Malcolm Turnbull, tertiary education in Australia has been opened up to the private sector in unprecedented ways.
As a result of these reforms, private education providers such as vocational colleges and institutes are now able to access federal government funding via the FEE-HELP system. This system plays a crucial role in Australian higher education, enabling students to study for expensive tertiary qualifications without paying anything upfront, by taking a loan out through the federal government. Without access to FEE-HELP, private colleges would find it much more difficult to sign up large numbers of domestic students.
As New Matilda has chronicled, the expansion of FEE-HELP to private colleges in the vocational sector has been a billion-dollar disaster for Australian education. Notorious swindlers like the Phoenix Institute and former stock market high-flyers Vocation moved into the sector, vacuumed up hundreds of millions of dollars in government education loans, and then collapsed.
The Top Education Institute is not without its own scandals. In May this year it was reported that TEI was offering internships at prestigious accounting firm PricewaterhouseCoopers. For a cool $2,800, prospective interns could “work closely with PwC partners”, according to an advertisement on social network WeChat. In response, PwC and Top Education then scrambled to explain the advertisement as a misunderstanding; apparently the positions were in fact only a two week ‘development’ course fee.
The arrangement between Top Education and PwC got murkier. In June this year PwC Australia acquired a 15 per cent stake in TOP Education. PwC and Top openly spruiked its investment in Top Education as an opportunity to get involved in the lucrative export education trade.
According to this article on Top Education’s website:
TOP Education’s Chair of Council and former Vice-Chancellor of La Trobe University, Emeritus Professor Brian Stoddart, said that TOP was delighted to align with PwC.“PwC recognises the value of investment in education export services and of the services already provided by TOP as a leading private innovator in the sector,” he said.
New Matilda is not suggesting Dr Zhu or Top Education have done anything improper. However the generous donations on the public record highlight the assiduous efforts Dr Zhu has made to court major party politicians.
Examining Top Education’s lobbying efforts suggests that the real play here is probably not Chinese soft power or political influence. In fact, the real value of Top Education’s generosity may be about securing a foothold position in Australia’s increasingly-privatised higher education market. The advantages for a private college looking to cash in on a boom in overseas students looking to study at private universities are manifest.
Posted by Ganesh Sahathevan at 5:33 PM
